Dapper Laughs returned to crossover boxing on two weeks’ notice and held Joey Essex to a four-round split draw, leaving Essex without the second Misfits victory he had sought.
The scorecards pulled in opposite directions. One judge returned 40-36, another scored it 37-39, and the third had it 38-38, producing a draw despite two officials choosing different winners.
For Daniel O’Reilly, the comedian behind Dapper Laughs, the result came after a lengthy spell away from the ring. His previous appearance had ended with a stoppage win over Simple Simon three years earlier.
Essex brought more recent experience.
He had beaten Numeiro on points in his Misfits debut last year, but O’Reilly’s return gave him a harder assignment than the short preparation might have suggested. Neither could turn a first boxing victory into a second.
The controversy centres on how differently the judges assessed the same four rounds. A shutout card sat alongside a verdict favouring the other fighter, while the drawn score ultimately prevented either from taking the decision.
That leaves a substantial disagreement. Across a contest this short, the gap between those cards puts the judging under scrutiny alongside the fighters’ performances.
O’Reilly’s case rested on his heavier connections, particularly the right hand, and the pressure he sustained in several exchanges. He also finished the fight driving Essex backwards, giving his corner reason to feel confident when the bell sounded.
Essex stayed in the argument.
His best response came when O’Reilly’s pace dipped, allowing him to advance and land his own right hand during the third. O’Reilly had success in that round too, forcing Essex towards the ropes with a two-punch attack before tiring late.
The fourth gave both a final opportunity to separate themselves. O’Reilly found further openings for his right hand and closed with a burst of punches as Essex tried to answer.
The bell ended the action without settling the result.
O’Reilly had made his heavier shots count from the opening round, but Essex continued to fire back and completed the distance. The judges’ divided verdict left the comedian’s strong finish unrewarded with a win and Essex’s follow-up to his debut victory incomplete.
There was a clearer outcome elsewhere on the card, where Big Stacks beat former West Ham defender James Collins by majority decision. Collins, a replacement for Thomas Skinner, recovered from a third-round knockdown and completed four rounds, with two judges awarding Stacks the fight.
